The dad sat in my office, fidgeting with his hands and looking uncomfortable. He told me a story about his daughter, 15 years old, who had decided she wanted a new smart phone like the ones her friends had, the kind that can surf the Internet, play music and videos, and make texting easy.
"I told her I wouldn't buy her a new phone because she already had one and it worked just fine," Dad told me. "Then she took the phone out of her purse, dropped it on the ground, and stomped on it with the heel of her boot. 'Now it's broken,' she said, 'and I need a new one.'" Looking faintly ashamed, the father looked up at me. "I guess what I need to know is whether I should buy her a new phone. I want her to have good self-esteem and to be happy...."
You're probably sitting at your computer thinking, "What a fool. I wouldn't buy that spoiled brat a single thing!" But I can guarantee you it's not that easy when the 15-year-old in question belongs to you.
Every generation of adults has had some version of the old saying, "These kids today!" Parents have always worried about the latest generational challenge, from hippies and drugs to the pernicious influence of the Viennese waltz. (I'm not kidding--it was a scandal in old Vienna.) But today's children and young adults seem to feel a sense of entitlement that is sobering in its depth. Parents tell me constantly that their children straight-up refuse to do homeowrk or chores, go to school or church, or cooperate unless they feel like it--and apparently, they don't often feel like it.
These entitled kids also seem to associate happiness with having stuff, and they believe that their parents are obligated to provide that stuff with no effort on their part. And parents, many of whom are self-assured, educated and successful people outside the home, turn into puddles of misery when confronted with a demanding, angry child. What on earth has happened?
I believe that kids these days do in fact have a deeper sense of privilege and entitlement than in generations past. There are many compassionate, hard-working, generous young people--but there are also many who are self-absorbed, unempathetic, and staggeringly selfish, who do not recognize the property rights or feelings of those around them. And I must gently suggest that responsibility for this situation rests solidly on the shoulders of their too-kind, not-firm-enough parents.
So here are a couple of things to consider as you navigate the treacherous waters of parental responsbility. First, value character over momentary happiness. Think about the sort of adult you want your child to become, the skills and character qualities you want that adult to have. Then consider whether your current approach to parenting is producing those qualities. Giving children everything they want, smoothing their path through life, and doing your best to ensure they never have to struggle or feel a moment's frustration may make them momentarily happy, but it strips them of the chance to learn patience, empathy, hard work, and gratitude.
Second, be willing to make the hard choices as a parent. Doing the right thing doesn't always feel good. Sometimes, when your child wants something--or expects to be rescued from life's responsibilities or the consequences of her own behavior--it is difficult to stand firm and follow through. Your child will be hurt, disappointed, or angry, and it is likely to become noisy and unpleasant in your living room. But these storms pass, and your child will have the opportunity to learn important life lessons--and perhaps, to learn to respect you.
Last but not least, practice being firm and kind. Firmness without kindness is harsh and is an invitation to power struggles. But kindness without firmness invites pampering and permissiveness--and a lifelong sense of entitlement that will not make your child a happy, productive adult. If you can say, with respect and dignity, "I love you and the answer is no," you're on the right path.
Parenting isn't easy and no one will do it perfectly. But it is essential to think about what your child will learn and decide from your choices, about herself and about the world around her.